How Many Chances Should a Racist Get?
Monique Chartier
In the view of a lot of people, one would be the limit. Mayor Susan Menard appears to be more forgiving.
The civil lawsuit filed in 2000 by Bennie Koffa outlines the treatment to which he was subjected by certain employees of the Woonsocket Highway Department including, notably, Robert Harnois. It came to light last week that Mr. Harnois, now Superintendent of that department, is the subject of a second, similar complaint by certain current highway department employees. The behavior described in the 2000 lawsuit, directed solely at Mr. Koffa as the only black person in the department, was disgusting and brutish.
Mayor Menard, who last year promoted Mr. Harnois to Superintendent of the Woonsocket Highway Department, has stated that she did not and does not believe the allegations in Mr. Koffa's lawsuit. The frequency, duration and number of witnesses - daily/over a year/many - of the verbal abuse considerably detracts from the credibility of her assertion.
Or, if we were to take her at her word, we would need to ask a couple of questions. In her capacity as mayor, how many other meritless lawsuits did she settle for six figures on behalf of the taxpayers of Woonsocket (and of the state)? How often in her capacity as mayor has she settled lawsuits sight unseen, without reviewing the substance of the case?
It is inexplicable that the mayor would promote a person who had been the subject not only of such accusations but of a taxpayer funded settlement involving such accusations. In doing so, she has exposed the city to a considerable financial liability. More importantly, she has condoned such rancid behavior.
A hypocritical question for this blog considering the tolerence it shows for blogger Mike who has written in Destroying Rhode Island No Joke:
you brain-addled, pedophile apoligist, government teat-sucker.
Please stop slandering me saying I have "Latin King pals".
I assurre you I have no black or brown "pals."
OldTimeLefty
Except, of course, that Mike is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative.
I am shocked, shocked! at Manolo's behavior.
She has her political gifts, though. A few years ago, she went after a swingers' club, which had been operating for quite awhile, at a politically opportune time, enabling her to present herself as the moral guardian of A City on the Move.
Remember, she still has powerful friends who enable her.
Old Time Lefty
Mike's comments are the gift,that keeps on giving.
He speaks for many,or most,of the right wingers that I know.
Justin PLEASE do not ban Mike's comments
Mike could be the next Chairman of the RI Republican Party
"A few years ago, she went after a swingers' club, which had been operating for quite awhile, at a politically opportune time, enabling her to present herself as the moral guardian of A City on the Move."
(... that's a good one, Rhody.)
No bid motorcycles, no bid copiers, questionable overtime, IOU's for the pension fund. It would have been preferable if she had focused, instead, on being the tax guardian of that City on the Move.
"Mike's comments are the gift,that keeps on giving.
He speaks for many,or most,of the right wingers that I know."
You have that right. Most just don't have the nuts to say it.
Oh-most of the ruling parties of Europe openly do-blacks and browns-OUT!
America as a Third World country-how progressive.
RI DESERVES THE WORST
LIZ ROBERTS FOR GOVERNOR
Monique -
Very good post. And important questions.
Does Mr. Harnois serve at the pleasure of the Mayor or is he in a collective bargaining unit?
These allegations - if true - certainly provide at least just cause.
-Matt
Justin,
your comment that "Mike is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative" might have some validity if you hadn't gone through the process of banning certain people from the blog while continually looking past mike's racist remarks.
You are an enabler, a Pilate washing his hands of the incident. You couldn't seem to extend the same blind eye towards David, to name one whom you have banned in the past. David "is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative" and you banned him.
Justice is blind, Justin peeks through the folds to see who is there before pronouncing judgment.
OldTimeLefty
I'm not sure I believe in banning, but any sane person who reads Mike's remarks can come to the same conclusion Lefty and I do.
It's Justin's forum. He who sponsors the bandwidth makes the rules. If he can shoulder the burden of defending Mike, more power to him.
rhody,
I don't favor banning. I am opposed to hypocritical posturing.
OldTimeLefty
Matt J:
Thank you.
As for your points, Mr. Harnois was promoted by the Mayor so she presumably also has the power to hire or terminate the person for that position. And he is now management. Usually, that would mean that he is not in a union.
In addition to being disgusting, in this day and age of micro recorders and max litigation, it is downright rash to employ such language. The main problem in this case, however, is the authority who knowingly promoted someone with such an anti-social and hostile attitude (towards certain people).
Monique
Thank you for bringing this to light. I am a reader of the incredible shrinking Providence Journal and had not heard the news from up north. The sort of behavior alleged here by a supervisor towards workers should not be condoned.
The latest on Mr. Harnois is that he hates just about everyone. Anyone he views as more stupid, fatter, uglier, he mocks to no end. Even the mayor, when she's not around, "she needs to go to the body shop."
Warns guys in the department not to go to the authorities on his many indiscretions or he'll see them outside later.
Click here for the new Anchor Rising & Ocean State Current page
About Community Crier
About Engaged Citizen
Administrator
A hypocritical question for this blog considering the tolerence it shows for blogger Mike who has written in Destroying Rhode Island No Joke:
OldTimeLefty Posted by: 0ldTimeLefty at March 15, 2009 10:46 PMExcept, of course, that Mike is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative.
Posted by: Justin Katz at March 15, 2009 10:52 PMI am shocked, shocked! at Manolo's behavior.
Posted by: rhody at March 15, 2009 11:34 PMShe has her political gifts, though. A few years ago, she went after a swingers' club, which had been operating for quite awhile, at a politically opportune time, enabling her to present herself as the moral guardian of A City on the Move.
Remember, she still has powerful friends who enable her.
Old Time Lefty
Mike's comments are the gift,that keeps on giving.
He speaks for many,or most,of the right wingers that I know.
Justin PLEASE do not ban Mike's comments
Mike could be the next Chairman of the RI Republican Party
Posted by: Harold at March 16, 2009 12:27 AM"A few years ago, she went after a swingers' club, which had been operating for quite awhile, at a politically opportune time, enabling her to present herself as the moral guardian of A City on the Move."
(... that's a good one, Rhody.)
No bid motorcycles, no bid copiers, questionable overtime, IOU's for the pension fund. It would have been preferable if she had focused, instead, on being the tax guardian of that City on the Move.
Posted by: Monique at March 16, 2009 6:50 AM"Mike's comments are the gift,that keeps on giving.
He speaks for many,or most,of the right wingers that I know."
You have that right. Most just don't have the nuts to say it.
Oh-most of the ruling parties of Europe openly do-blacks and browns-OUT!
America as a Third World country-how progressive.
Posted by: Mike at March 16, 2009 8:38 AMRI DESERVES THE WORST
LIZ ROBERTS FOR GOVERNOR
Monique -
Very good post. And important questions.
Does Mr. Harnois serve at the pleasure of the Mayor or is he in a collective bargaining unit?
These allegations - if true - certainly provide at least just cause.
-Matt
Posted by: Matt Jerzyk at March 16, 2009 1:19 PMJustin,
your comment that "Mike is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative" might have some validity if you hadn't gone through the process of banning certain people from the blog while continually looking past mike's racist remarks.
You are an enabler, a Pilate washing his hands of the incident. You couldn't seem to extend the same blind eye towards David, to name one whom you have banned in the past. David "is a voice in the crowd, not a paid (and promoted) official representative" and you banned him.
Justice is blind, Justin peeks through the folds to see who is there before pronouncing judgment.
Posted by: OldTimeLefty at March 16, 2009 3:21 PMOldTimeLefty
I'm not sure I believe in banning, but any sane person who reads Mike's remarks can come to the same conclusion Lefty and I do.
Posted by: rhody at March 16, 2009 7:20 PMIt's Justin's forum. He who sponsors the bandwidth makes the rules. If he can shoulder the burden of defending Mike, more power to him.
rhody,
Posted by: OldTimeLefty at March 16, 2009 7:47 PMI don't favor banning. I am opposed to hypocritical posturing.
OldTimeLefty
Matt J:
Thank you.
As for your points, Mr. Harnois was promoted by the Mayor so she presumably also has the power to hire or terminate the person for that position. And he is now management. Usually, that would mean that he is not in a union.
In addition to being disgusting, in this day and age of micro recorders and max litigation, it is downright rash to employ such language. The main problem in this case, however, is the authority who knowingly promoted someone with such an anti-social and hostile attitude (towards certain people).
Posted by: Monique at March 16, 2009 9:27 PMMonique
Thank you for bringing this to light. I am a reader of the incredible shrinking Providence Journal and had not heard the news from up north. The sort of behavior alleged here by a supervisor towards workers should not be condoned.
Posted by: Phil at March 17, 2009 7:44 AMThe latest on Mr. Harnois is that he hates just about everyone. Anyone he views as more stupid, fatter, uglier, he mocks to no end. Even the mayor, when she's not around, "she needs to go to the body shop."
Posted by: Jake at March 20, 2009 12:26 PMWarns guys in the department not to go to the authorities on his many indiscretions or he'll see them outside later.