March 21, 2013

Who's Being Served By Single Party Voting?

Patrick Laverty

Who gets the most benefit of the "master lever" as Ken Block has been calling it (or single party, or straight ticket or straight party). For consistency, we'll call it the master lever (ML). Some of those elected to the Statehouse have even been so brazen to come right out and admit that they like the ML because it helps them to stay in office and they oppose its elimination. What if we take a look at this self-serving attitude by the numbers.

The last column shows what percentage of that legislator's vote total came from the master lever. Looking at these numbers shows the correlation between getting high numbers of master lever votes and being opposed to eliminating the master lever. "Don't bite the hand that feeds you."

House
District
Winner For/Against Dem Lever
/Total Vote
12 Almeida For 71.4%
9 Williams Against 62.6%
11 Diaz Against 62.6%
56 Silva Against 61.1%
3 Palangio Against 58.3%
10 Slater For 56.8%
58 San Bento Against 51.8%
13 Carnevale Against 49.7%
8 Lombardi For 48.7%
59 O'Neill Against 48.2%
60 Coderre Against 46.9%
7 Cimini For 46.0%
62 Messier Against 37.8%
2 Blazejewski Against 37.6%
64 Melo Against 36.7%
5 DeSimone Against 35.7%
14 Lima For 35.1%
49 Baldelli-Hunt For 33.5%
57 McLaughlin For 32.9%
6 Hull For 32.7%
61 Johnston, Jr. Against 28.8%
73 Abney Against 26.5%
4 Fox Against 23.6%
55 Corvese Against 22.3%
1 Ajello For 22.1%
63 Kazarian Against 22.1%
25 Nunes For 21.7%
50 Csey Against 21.5%
75 Martin For 21.2%
51 Phillips Against 20.8%
42 Ucci Against 20.0%
18 Handy For 19.0%
65 Amore For 18.7%
54 O'Brien Against 17.4%
43 Fellela Against 16.9%
20 Bennett For 16.4%
17 Jaquard For 15.8%
16 Palumbo For 15.5%
45 Ackerman For 15.1%
21 Naughton Against 15.1%
37 Azzinaro Against 15.0%
70 Edwards For 14.1%
69 Gallison, Jr. Against 13.8%
71 Canario Against 13.8%
27 Serpa Against 13.7%
26 Morgan For 13.7%
22 Ferri For 13.2%
74 Ruggiero For 13.0%
28 Guthrie Against 12.9%
19 McNamara For 12.3%
46 O'Grady For 12.2%
52 MacBeth For 12.1%
47 Keable Against 11.8%
24 Trillo For 11.4%
66 Hearn For 11.4%
29 Tomasso For 11.3%
38 Kennedy Against 11.3%
34 Tanzi For 11.0%
23 Shekarchi Against 10.7%
67 Malik For 10.5%
68 Marshall Against 10.2%
33 Lally Against 10.2%
39 Valencia For 10.1%
53 Winfield Against 9.9%
44 Costantino For 9.5%
72 Finn For 9.5%
31 Costa For 9.3%
48 Newberry For 8.8%
36 Walsh For 8.6%
35 Dickinson For 8.4%
32 Craven For 8.3%
15 Mattiello Against 8.3%
40 Chippendale For 7.4%
41 Marcello For 7.3%
30 Giarusso For 6.8%

Just looking at those numbers, the 27 of the top 50 (54%) are opposed to eliminating the master lever. Only 7 of the bottom 25 (28%) are opposed to eliminating the master lever.

On the Senate side, we have similar numbers. Among those in the top half for getting master lever votes, 62% more of them are opposed to eliminating the master lever than the bottom half.

Senate
District
Winner For/Against Dem Lever
/total vote
6 Metts Against 62.9%
2 Pichardo Against 59.3%
16 Crowley For 57.8%
1 Goodwin Against 52.0%
5 Jabour Against 49.6%
7 Ciccone, III Against 41.4%
15 Nesselbush For 40.7%
14 DaPonte Against 31.6%
8 Doyle, II Against 31.3%
24 Cote For 29.2%
18 Conley, Jr. For 25.1%
3 Goldin Against 22.9%
4 Ruggerio Against 21.9%
20 Picard For 21.3%
25 Lombardo, III For 20.7%
28 Miller Against 19.6%
12 DiPalma Against 16.8%
13 Paiva-Weed Against 16.2%
9 Satchell Against 15.6%
10 Felag, Jr. Against 15.2%
32 Bates For 14.8%
26 Lombardi Against 14.5%
38 Algiere For 14.4%
11 Ottiano For 14.3%
31 Lynch Against 14.0%
19 Pearson Against 13.4%
29 McCaffrey Against 13.3%
33 Raptakis For 12.5%
22 Archambault Against 11.8%
27 Gallo Against 11.2%
17 O'Neill For 10.6%
30 Walaska For 10.1%
37 Sosnowski For 9.8%
34 Rumsey For 9.7%
36 Sheehan For 9.5%
23 Fogarty Against 9.3%
21 Kettle For 8.8%
35 Hodgson For 1.1%

Yes, there are outliers on both ends, there are in just about any data set. But is the purpose of the master lever to keep the incumbents elected? I've never heard anyone say that is the purpose of having the mechanism. Actually, I'm still yet to hear a good reason for keeping it. Then when you add on to that the fact that having the master lever as an option disenfranchises voters, we don't need much more evidence to show that this needs to go immediately.

Comments, although monitored, are not necessarily representative of the views Anchor Rising's contributors or approved by them. We reserve the right to delete or modify comments for any reason.
Post a comment









Remember personal info?

Important note: The text "http:" cannot appear anywhere in your comment.