The Marriage Debate in the Wake of the Buckley Conservative Movement

For the opening speech of the Portsmouth Institute’s Friday session, Maggie Gallagher traced the effects of a few cultural (particularly marital) trends on the conservative fusionism that William F. Buckley, Jr., helped to develop.

Some highlights:

  • On the character Bill Buckley cut for himself by “refusing to grow” (meaning to become gradually more liberal upon becoming famous). Stream, download (52 sec).
  • On the left’s attack on conservative fusionism, assuming neutrality and leveraging Americans’ general prosperity. The focus of this audio clip is abortion, but the interesting application to the same-sex marriage issue comes, first, in the further challenge of the notion that cultural traditionalism can coexist with limited government and, second, in the disallowance of traditionalists to continue to practice their faiths without bowing, in the public square, to a radical proclamation on marriage. Stream, download (2 min, 5 sec).
  • On the intellectual difficulty that divorce and same-sex marriage present to those who wish to choose a traditional marital arrangement, in which both sides agree on the indissoluble nature of the relationship — are enabled, that is, to make vows that they truly know mean in the eyes of the law what they profess them to mean. Stream, download (3 min, 25 sec)
  • On the same-sex marriage movement’s attempt to make marriage address the cultural problem of toleration in such a way as to detract from the institution’s ability to address its own mission. Stream, download (59 sec)
  • On the danger (especially for cultural conservatism) that the traditionalism of the creative class — in which group Gallagher includes business people, especially entrepreneurs — are breaking away from the structures of society that have nourished our own. Stream, download (2 min, 25 sec)
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
11 years ago

On Divorce……………
Can you name a right-wingnut leader who
has not been divorced ????
Palin (coming soon)
Dave Vitter (next up
Larry Craig (wow $$$)
Sen John Ensign (new)
Fred Thompson
ect ect the list is to long
just google \”right wing adulterers\”

11 years ago

Yeah, because Democrats who stay married for political convenience are SUCH a better example.

11 years ago

Divorce and marital infidelity happens to all peoples, of all parties. It’s the folks like Limbaugh, Vitter and Ensign who got self-righteous about it (as if they are above human failings), and look worse when they stumble.

Show your support for Anchor Rising with a 25-cent-per-day subscription.