Justin Katz

The Helplessness of Being the Joke

By Justin Katz | April 29, 2007 |

It’s a tricky business responding to the personal anecdotes that opinionists sometimes use in their columns. The reader was not there, for one thing, and it isn’t always evident what emotions the memory revives, for another. But the stories are offered, ostensibly for the purpose of illustrating an important point relevant to current events, and…

The Victims of Our Lack of Self Control

By Justin Katz | April 28, 2007 |

Peggy Noonan gets it exactly right in her recent musing about modern media’s effect on children: For 50 years in America, whenever the subject has turned to what our culture presents, the bright response has been, “You don’t like it? Change the channel.” But there is no other channel to change to, no safe place…

Re: Poverty Rate Versus Tax Burden

By Justin Katz | April 28, 2007 |

It’s worth noting, as an addendum to Andrew’s post, that the two metrics aren’t merely correlative. A substantial portion of the tax revenue goes toward those sorts of programs that attract poor people to the state (see, e.g., here, here, and here). In other words, the option is more likely to be “all of the…

Abortion Falsehoods and Truths

By Justin Katz | April 26, 2007 |

The Providence Journal’s editorial on the Supreme Court’s partial-birth abortion ruling isn’t quite as deceptive/deluded as Mary Ann Sorrentino’s, but at the very least, it’s misleading (emphasis added): The U.S. Supreme Court’s 5-to-4 decision upholding the right of the federal government to impose a ban on a certain form of rarely performed second-trimester abortion is…

Wingfield’s Letter

By Justin Katz | April 26, 2007 |

Inasmuch as it is difficult to discuss a document that is not readily available to the public, herewith is Ethan Wingfield’s letter of resignation as Chairman of the College Republican Federation of Rhode Island (printed with permission): To all, I write this evening to announce my resignation as Chairman of the College Republican Federation of…

Civility — It’s Not Just for Winners!

By Justin Katz | April 23, 2007 |

I’ll be the first to admit that it’s all too easy, while in the rapture of our rightness, to lose sight of the fact that we’re in the minority in this state… by a lot. So outnumbered are we that the Warwick Daily Times’s imbalanced labelling of blogs needn’t be seen as an unmitigated example…

Giving and Taking Unions

By Justin Katz | April 18, 2007 |

After slipping into another certainly fruitless discussion with a certain of our regular commenters, it occurred to me that one of humanity’s detrimental tendencies, with particular implications for modern society, is to think of societal mechanisms with too narrow of a focus, usually adjusted to the breadth at which our preferences appear clearest. The case…

Humanity in a Brave New World

By Justin Katz | April 16, 2007 |

At the risk of confirming suspicions of conservatives’ reactionary squeamishness, I have to admit to huge, visceral aversion to this sort of thing: Women might soon be able to produce sperm in a development that could allow lesbian couples to have their own biological daughters, according to a pioneering study published today. Scientists are seeking…

Circumnavigating Marriage… Again

By Justin Katz | April 15, 2007 |

I have intended to keep up my end of the same-sex marriage conversation with Matt of Unlikely Words, but various factors have delayed my doing so. For one thing, life keeps trying to trip me up (in ways stated and hinted on Dust in the Light and in ways kept private). Perhaps a more significant,…

Re: The Confluence of Homosexuality and Abortion

By Justin Katz | April 11, 2007 |

Contra Ian Donnis, you can make this stuff up: Mohler began by summarizing some recent research into sexual orientation, and advising his Christian readership that they should brace for the possibility that a biological basis for homosexuality may be proven. Mohler wrote that such proof would not alter the Bible’s condemnation of homosexuality, but said…