Labor

Banking on a System Sure to Fail

By Justin Katz | May 13, 2008 |

Andrew makes a central observation in the comments to his latest post on the pension deficit: If politicians making bad fiscal decisions are the entire story of the pension funding crisis, that is a strong case against defined benefit plans, because there is no reason to believe that current and future pols are going to…

Ending Bumping

By Justin Katz | May 12, 2008 |

Perhaps no practice is a better distillation of the blight that is teacher unionization than bumping. I’m with Julia Steiny in thinking that it ought to end, but the suggestions of the Business Education Partnership that she describes in her column, yesterday, are worth considering as half-way measures: To professionalize education personnel practices, Blais and…

Doing a Job on the State

By Justin Katz | May 6, 2008 |

James Cournoyer, of North Smithfield, gets to the heart of the matter (after noting that public employees are paid workers, not volunteers): … a public employee who starts working at age 25 with a $30,000 salary and annual raises of 3.25 percent will contribute $74,425 to the pension system over 20 years, assuming a contribution…

Re: Re: Another Reason to Private School in Rhode Island

By Justin Katz | May 3, 2008 |

Actually, what struck me about Rhody’s comment was how this early sentence betrays the ridiculousness of his point: If any of us were sent back to work under a court order, our attitude might not be that great, either. Most of us, I venture to suggest, cannot envision circumstances in which a court would have…

Another Reason to Private School in Rhode Island

By Justin Katz | May 3, 2008 |

Here’s another shining example of what public sector unions — specifically teachers’ unions, specifically the NEA — have wrought: The state Department of Education does not endorse the high school’s plan for students to stand before their English classes to present their senior projects — a new graduation requirement here this year. … Most of…

What a Crock

By Justin Katz | April 26, 2008 |

Pat Crowley’s complaints about a letter that Governor Carcieri apparently sent to Bob Walsh, Crowley’s NEA boss, are transparently two-faced in so many ways that I won’t enumerate them. Simply put, the idea that Walsh would respond otherwise than with the mind-numbing reply that Crowley publishes is laughable. It is, let’s just say, improbable that…

Feinting Round One

By Justin Katz | April 26, 2008 |

Surely, I’ve become too apt to be suspicious, but something in this labor rep’s reaction to the supplemental budget — in conjunction with the legislators’ “yelling and screaming” during debate of it — reminds me that this was merely the preface: “It’s devastating,” said Dennis Grilli, head of the largest state employees union, Council 94.…

Why Should a Study Focus on the Underlying Problem?

By Justin Katz | April 25, 2008 |

Here’s the laugh line from Jill Rodrigues’s Sakonnet Times story on the professional study that concluded — shockingly — that the Portsmouth school system needs more money: Although much of that money is spent on salaries and benefits, the consultants did not weigh in on contract provisions and their impacts on the district. Reading some…

Woe Is the Early Retiree

By Justin Katz | April 24, 2008 |

Steve Peoples’s story, which Marc mentioned earlier, of the likely mass retirement of public workers wishing to retain the current healthcare deal for retirees emanates cognitive dissonance. How are readers expected to react to this: Sheila Ellis waited for nearly an hour inside the stuffy reception area of the state retirement office yesterday afternoon. And…

After Further Thought

By Justin Katz | April 12, 2008 |

I’ve most likely been overstating the number of Tiverton teachers who stand to lose their jobs if the union remains implacable. Thirty-four notices of potential layoffs went out to meet a deadline; one position was eliminated in the school budget as passed; so I’ve been saying that intransigence might result in the actual layoffs of…