Religion

Portsmouth Institute Second Annual Conference, Newman and the Intellectual Tradition, Day One

By Justin Katz | June 11, 2010 |

It’s hard to believe that it’s been a full year since I attended and covered the first annual conference of the Portsmouth Institute of the Portsmouth Abbey School in (you guessed it) Portsmouth, Rhode Island. I’ll admit that, as much as I’ve looked forward to this event, the disruption of my habits and quotidian obligations…

A Lament of Superficial Opposition

By Justin Katz | June 2, 2010 |

David Hart is, above all, disappointed at the recent wave of “New Atheists” — at their superficiality and intellectual laziness, at the way (in essence) they present themselves as petulant adolescents still impressed with the fact that God does not strike them dead when they turn mom’s crucifix upside down. Hart mainly wishes for some…

Legal, but Gone

By Justin Katz | May 17, 2010 |

So, the Mojave Desert cross honoring American servicemen and -women has been stolen: A cross erected on a remote Mojave Desert outcropping to honor American war dead has been stolen less than two weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court allowed it to remain standing while a legal battle continued over its presence on federal land.…

Mainly a Question of Power

By Justin Katz | May 3, 2010 |

My Rhode Island Catholic column for April takes up the interaction of Jesus and Pilate, with its lessons about power: The striking thing, if Jesus told Pilate to label Him as he did, is that Caesar’s representatives clearly had the power to kill the corporeal King of the Jews. Moreover, the fact that Jesus did…

How the Accommodating Institution Declines

By Justin Katz | May 2, 2010 |

Apparently, in fields that debate such things, there’s been an attempt to apply economic principles to explain the ebbs and flows of attendance in different churches. John Lamont does some difference splitting and paints a persuasive picture (subscription required). Because “the rewards of religion are supernatural and, therefore, unseen,” the healthy religion, he explains, requires…

Rethinking Paul

By Justin Katz | May 1, 2010 |

From college-level religious history courses to tracts on same-sex marriage, one hears of St. Paul as the strict counterpoint to Jesus’ universal acceptance. I’d argue that the image of Jesus as the undemanding forgiver is fundamentally flawed, but Sarah Ruden — here, as summarized in a review of her book by John Wilson — puts…

Separation Doesn’t Mean That One Silences the Other

By Justin Katz | May 1, 2010 |

By way of follow-up on an issue that I’ve mentioned, before, the Supreme Court has ruled that a plain cross on public land in the middle of the desert does not constitute an establishment of religion: By a 5-4 vote, the justices reversed lower courts in California that ordered the U.S. Park Service to remove…

The Reaction, Not the Rejection, Is the Thing

By Justin Katz | April 24, 2010 |

In their capacity as literature, the texts of the Bible aren’t exclusively of religious concern. (That’s hardly an original or incendiary suggestion.) So perhaps you’ll find this reading of Cain and Abel — found in a review by Shalom Carmy of a book by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks — worth a few moments of sunny…

Bishop Tobin Won’t Let Catholicism Just Be a Brand

By Justin Katz | April 23, 2010 |

As much as it’s disappointing to see division among Catholic organizations, unity can’t be the core principle of any group that actually believes in anything. That is to say that I think Bishop Thomas Tobin got this one right: Following a statement issued by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops expressing regret that health care…

Handing Charitable Authority to the State

By Justin Katz | April 23, 2010 |

In a recent iteration of his editor’s column for First Things, Joseph Bottum takes up the topic of the branches of religious organizations that reside at the edges of the organized church, itself, what he calls “limicole institutions”: As [Archbishop] Chaput notes, the first leverage typically used is financial. Public bureaucrats and lawmakers pressure Catholic…