Religion

Diocesan Priests Ordered to Deny Communion? Congressman Kennedy Says Yes, Bishop Tobin Says No.

By Carroll Andrew Morse | November 22, 2009 |

Bishop of Providence Thomas Tobin and Rhode Island First District Congressman Kennedy are offering two different versions of the latest consequences resulting from Congressman Kennedy’s public statement that a true pro-life position requires the Catholic Church to support a healthcare plan that includes public funding for abortions (h/t commenter “Tim”, who pointed to this Ray…

Also About Refashioning America

By Justin Katz | November 22, 2009 |

A fair number of people who might be said to lean right — libertarians and moderates and such — would do well to consider a review of the current standing of Catholic charities by Archbishop Charles Chaput, of Denver: When we look closely at Church-state conflicts in America, we see that they now often center…

Deny Fathers (and Reality) at Your Peril

By Justin Katz | November 20, 2009 |

Fr. John Kiley makes an excellent point in an RI Catholic column that is, for some reason, not online: And it is not just television that demeans men. Catholics would be surprised how often a priest goes to another parish to celebrate Mass only to find all the male pronouns penciled out of the Sacramentary…

Kennedy’s Church of Personal Influence

By Justin Katz | November 18, 2009 |

One aspect of the controversy between Congressman Patrick Kennedy and Bishop Thomas Tobin with a broader application is Kennedy’s misunderstanding of religion’s place in life: U.S. Rep. Patrick Kennedy said he was “not going to dignify with an answer” Roman Catholic Bishop Thomas J. Tobin’s public comments that Kennedy could not be a good Catholic…

Interfaith Community Aligns Against Laypeople

By Justin Katz | November 17, 2009 |

There can be no doubt that our society is better off with religious leaders who consistently urge against heated discord than who use their influence to rally factions against each other. I worry, though, that this level of disposition to unite with other religious leaders against impliedly barbaric masses comes at the cost of any…

Death, Taxes, and the Impossibility of Separation

By Justin Katz | November 13, 2009 |

In an essay in the current issue of The RI Catholic, I attempt to link my conversion from nihilism to Catholicism with the impossibility of truly separating church and state by way of introducing my heretofore monthly column in the publication: Faith-filled or faithless, no such existential philosophies can be sopped off the skin like…

A Memory of Now

By Justin Katz | November 8, 2009 |

If you’re of a mind to direct your thoughts away from the particulars of the day — shootings and bombs and recession and government expansion — David Goldman’s essay on the use of rhythm and expectation to imbue a sense of the sacred into music is worth your time. There is a point, though, where…

The Origin of Anti-Semitism

By Justin Katz | November 7, 2009 |

Perhaps it’s peculiar, given my Jewish heritage, or perhaps it’s entirely predictable, given my progression from atheism to Catholicism, but I’d never thought to explain anti-Semitism in the way that Meir Soloveichik describes here: As Stanley Hauerwas notes, Berkovits fails to understand that “societies putatively founded on values of ‘universal validity’ cannot help but interpret…

Absolutes Only Halt Debate When They Meet with Intransigence

By Justin Katz | November 6, 2009 |

I’m straining for a silver lining, to be sure, but Congressman Patrick Kennedy does offer the useful service, from time to time, of stating rhetoric that is sufficiently blunt to expose the error underneath. With reference to the fight he picked with the Catholic Church: Kennedy also said that no group “is getting everything it…

A Biological Ghetto

By Justin Katz | November 6, 2009 |

In the June/July issue of First Things, Mary Eberstadt suggested commonality between pro-lifers and vegetarians that (she thinks) justifies closer affiliation. Think what you may about the thesis, on which I’m not sold, a subsequent letter from a gentleman named Gerald Lame brings us back to dualism: So Eberstadt’s “moral traditionalists” are really animist-vitalists. And…