Poor Diagnoses, or Munchausen by Proxy?

Rhode Island Kids Count’s Jill Beckwith is correct that Rhode Island is “heading in the wrong direction” when it comes to healthcare. According to Projo Medical Writer Felice Freyer, fewer Rhode Island workers have healthcare coverage, a higher percentage of children are without it, and yet:

Rhode Island spends a higher proportion of its economy and its state budget on health care than the rest of New England and the nation.

Why, then, do three of the four recommendations that Freyer reports from “a first-of-its-kind report” by the state’s health insurance commissioner, Christopher Koller, call for increased public aid, with the fourth suggesting that the state “require employers to offer health insurance and individuals to buy it”? Either the problem is being misdiagnosed, or the care-for-you community in the public sphere has a social manifestation of Munchausen by proxy (the disease that led that mother in The Sixth Sense to spoon Pine-Sole into her daughter’s soup).
Don’t misunderstand: requiring people to buy their own health insurance is a key component of the solution that I’ve increasingly been favoring, but in typical Rhode Island fashion, it looks as if the powers that be are fixin’ to get it all wrong. Expanding the number of people who can claim publicly funded insurance while leaning on companies and slightly wealthier individuals (such as those at three times the poverty level), and while taking no steps to decrease regulations or draw additional insurers to our local market, will only reinforce the trends that are killing the state.
If, for instance, RI Senate Majority Leader Teresa Paiva Weed should decide to act on her observation that (in Freyer’s words) “it may be difficult to regulate large employers because many are self-insured,” large employers will have one more incentive leave, even as disproportionate handouts continue to spur the needy to come.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
bam in barrington
bam in barrington
16 years ago

Yes, perhaps the time for mandatory health insurance has come.(We have mandatory automobile insurance, don’t we?)
I have friends in Switzerland whom I see three or four times a year here in the US (will see them in a few weeks.) Here’s the story on health insurance in Switzerland: Health insurance mandatory for all; costs approximately what it does here in the US; no medicare or medicaid; subsidies available to those unable to afford paying the full premiums.
Switzerland is a very conservative country. They do not have “socialized medicine.” Per capita income in Switzerland is approximatly what it is in RI, i.e. $31,500 per year.
Will attempt to get more information when I see my friends, such as, employer provided or not?
It will be interesting as to how mandatory health insurance plays out in Massachusetts (where I work.)

Show your support for Anchor Rising with a 25-cent-per-day subscription.