Roundtable Redux

Anybody who missed my appearance on WRNI’s Political Roundtable on Friday can find the audio here. There were two points that I didn’t manage to work into the extremely rapid format:

  1. In response to Scott MacKay’s suggestion that the Roman Catholic Church would find its pews empty were it to be as intransigent on every issue as it is on abortion (vis Patrick Kennedy), it ought to be pointed out that few issues are as stark and straightforward as abortion. On one level, there is no room for prudential judgment on the question of whether it’s morally proper to deliberately kill children for any reason short of life-and-death. On another level, there isn’t really much room to work prudential judgment around abortion. In healthcare, for example, additional funding for abortion will be used for that purpose, but the expanded coverage and “improvements” to the healthcare system that Kennedy (for example) cited as justifying compromise are wholly prospective — mostly suspect.
  2. Regarding Gordon Fox’s day out at the ballpark with lobbyists, I would have liked to point out the effect of this whole frame of mind on the citizenry. Fox (to recap) sat in a $120 seat purchased by GTECH lobbyists at a Red Sox game and claims to have paid his way. Whatever the specifics of the case, if a carpenter like me were to be elected to office and err in judgment over a $100 sports ticket, the potential $10,000 fine would be devastating. Another problem with the oppressive effort to pluck all influence peddling from government is the adverse effect of making government a game that only people insulated from the risks can play. Shrinking government would be a better approach.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scott Bill Hirst
Scott Bill Hirst
11 years ago

Hi!
Regardless how one feels about abortion, politically it is a double edge sword. Legally a woman’s right to abortion exists per various court decisions as well as legislation. Until the United States Supreme Court changes its position or a Constitutional amendment changes it, for the forseeable future abortion will be permitted at least in some cases.
Restrictions are possible certainly, per court decisions also, and legislation that meets constitutional and federal law criteria can restrict it in some areas. It may be difficult legally to require funding for abortions or get many to support public funding for it, abortion cannot legally be eliminated at this time.
It needs to be remembered not all theologians and clergy agree on the abortion issue, as well others in other fields and the general public.
Regards,
Scott

Show your support for Anchor Rising with a 25-cent-per-day subscription.