Memo to Bishops: Don’t Fall For It
The Washington Post has collected a spectrum of religious reactions to the Obama administration’s “compromise” — apparently announced as such without first consulting with the parties implicitly involved in the negotiations (a sure sign that Obama is more concerned about appearing to compromise than actually doing so). Religious leaders and others concerned about religious liberty — in particular those concerned about our ability to work through cultural avenues distinct from government to help shape society — should pause in their deliberations about the specifics of this overture.
Note what position the President’s games put us in: We’re not arguing about the morality of contraception (including abortifacients). We’re not even arguing about the legitimacy of the government’s declaration that everybody should have access to them free of cost (at least free of immediate cost to them). We’re merely arguing about who else must pay — who has to chip in for the pills that address pregnancy as an illness to be treated and against which to be inoculated.
One hopes that the administration’s initial overreach was enough to awaken the bishops and others to the reality that a deal with the Devil is always, always conditional on his ability to force you to the next-least-moral space on the playing field.