Labor

Okay, I’ll Bite

By Justin Katz | October 24, 2009 |

Presumably, Pat Crowley — by his strenuous logical standards — would also believe that we needn’t listen to pacifists, or even military minimalists, were we to consider dropping a nuclear bomb on Iran: Look, if the answer is you simply don’t believe teachers have the right to collectively bargain, I wish you would stop beating…

“Modified” Binding Arbitration: A Bad Idea is Still Bad Even if It’s Tweaked

By Monique Chartier | October 22, 2009 |

Following upon a very well attended hearing yesterday, Opponents clogged the State House committee room, spilling into the marble hallway and lining the walls. Some held signs of protest above their heads for hours. It was an unusual display for a workday hearing on a legislative proposal entitled simply, “School Teacher Arbitration.” the Providence Journal’s…

Andrew & Matt Talk Binding Arbitration

By Justin Katz | October 22, 2009 |

Last night’s Anchor Rising on the Matt Allen Show was a bit more expansive than usual, as Andrew and Matt discussed binding arbitration’s relationship to governing philosophy. Stream by clicking here, or download it.

ProJo Notices the Stacked Arbitration Deck

By Marc Comtois | October 21, 2009 |

A couple days ago I noticed that, with the arbitration bill coming up, Sen. John Tassoni had just been approved as a mediator. (The ProJo story reporting this also mentioned a few others). That led me to remark that it looked like the arbitration/mediation deck was being stacked ahead of time. The ProJo editors have…

Should Arbitration Rulings Outrank the Law? It’s a Feature, not a Bug Say Advocates!

By Carroll Andrew Morse | October 21, 2009 |

I’m not entirely sure how authoritative this reference is, but the website called Rhode Island Arbitration –dot- com is promoting the fact that the decisions of arbitrators can take precedence over the law…Did You Know…Courts cannot overturn an arbitration award. Typically, the courts cannot overturn an arbitration award because the arbitrator made a mistake of…

Binding Arbitration, the Board Game

By Justin Katz | October 19, 2009 |

Let’s you and I play a game. We’ll start out with you giving me a certain sum of money. Then every five minutes, I’ll propose how much more money you should give me, and you can propose a slightly lower increase, and if I refuse to accept those terms, we’ll take our disagreement to a…

RE: Binding Arbitration

By Marc Comtois | October 19, 2009 |

As Monique notes, the bill requiring binding arbitration in union/town disputes is slated to be heard this Wednesday. You can also hear NEA/AFT funded radio advertisements touting the bill. I wonder why labor unions–which traditionally take pride in being negotiating pit bulls–are apparently going all warm and fuzzy over the prospect of a supposedly fair…

Broke by Binding

By Justin Katz | October 18, 2009 |

I’ve got an op-ed in the upcoming Providence Business News addressing a topic that’s on a great many Rhode Island minds: binding arbitration.

Work of the Hand Is Not Exclusive of the Mind

By Justin Katz | October 16, 2009 |

Marc’s post on education and “dirty jobs” — the entire recent discussion about college and the necessity thereof — brings to mind this passage from Walter Rose’s wonderful book The Village Carpenter, which reflects on Rose’s family business as the era of the automobile and the machine came on strong: These words are not to…

Is the Gig Up for the RI Education Industry?

By Justin Katz | October 13, 2009 |

It’s worth your time, if you haven’t already read through the Sunday Providence Journal article about RI Education Commissioner Deborah Gist’s elevation of the state’s standardized test requirement for prospective education students to the highest in the country. The college and university estimates of how many students would miss the mark are head shakers, but…