Religion

Somehow It’s Worse When It’s Past, I Guess

By Justin Katz | October 15, 2010 |

Here’s an interesting incident from an article about expanding restrictions on counter-Islamic blasphemy in and out of the Muslim world: In Kabul in 2008, Ghaus Zalmai and Mushtaq Ahmad were each sentenced to 20 years in prison for publishing a Dari translation of the Koran (the translator was U.S. resident Qudratullah Bakhtiarinejad). The minister for…

From Allah’s Lips to the King’s Ear

By Justin Katz | October 14, 2010 |

Here’s a fascinating dynamic, not only for the Muslim state, but the perspective that factions of the West might bring of it: Now King Abdullah is moving to regain control over this abundance of fatwas. Under a royal decree issued in mid-August, only the official panel may issue the fatwas that answer every question of…

While We’re Condemning Threats

By Justin Katz | September 18, 2010 |

I’m sure it’s just taking some time for transreligion councils to organize their press conferences over this story: The Seattle cartoonist whose artwork sparked the controversial “Everybody Draw Muhammad Day!” has gone into hiding at the advice of the FBI after being targeted by a radical Muslim cleric, according to the newspaper that published her…

Unidirectional Interfaith Statements

By Justin Katz | September 16, 2010 |

It’s often subtle — and I certainly don’t mean to discourage interaction between leaders of different religions — but it does seem as if the statements of unity all follow a, well, a non-objective narrative. After an apparently religiously inspired multiple murder, an act of terrorism, to be blunt, this was the message of the…

A Judgmental Pendulum

By Justin Katz | September 12, 2010 |

A mid-August column by Fr. John Kiley has been swinging in the background of my mind: In spite of this legacy of warnings about the gravity of the end times, the prospect of final judgment and any thought of ultimate justice have almost disappeared from the modern Christian mind. Saturday afternoon lines at the confessional…

The Confusion of Success with the Meaning of Life

By Justin Katz | September 1, 2010 |

Some strains of Darwinian secularism are speckled throughout with signs of the mansions and vast estates of their most prominent promoters. Such appears to be the case with Matt Ridley’s philosophy, as presented in George Gilder’s review of his book The Rational Optimist: How Prosperity Evolves: Reason, to Ridley’s mind, impels us relentlessly forward and…

An Argument for a Burqa Ban

By Justin Katz | August 31, 2010 |

The Islamic practice of women’s veiling, extending to the absurd and offensive burqa, presents difficult questions for the West. Who are we, we wonder, to trample other cultures voluntarily perpetuated? Worse yet is the question of whether a society can stop intolerance once it has granted itself permission to discriminate against that which it finds…

Self-Serving Accusations of Hypocrisy

By Justin Katz | August 30, 2010 |

I’m not sure what inspired the Providence Journal to transport this essay from one coast to another, but with the assumption that the objective was to begin debate, rather than conclude it, I thought it worth taking up. The argument of William Lobdell’s broadside on religious Americans, initially published in the LA Times, is that…

In Favor of a “Demanding” Religion

By Justin Katz | August 15, 2010 |

Undemanding religions decline. Such is the consequence of an argument that John Lamont — a professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame Australia — made in a recent article for the journal, First Things. Religions with somewhat arduous rules dissuade “free riders” — those seeking the benefits of membership without cost. Additionally, traditions…

Word on the Page

By Justin Katz | August 8, 2010 |

It won’t be to everyone’s interests, but R.R. Reno’s commentary on biblical exegesis is worth a read (see here if you don’t subscribe to First Things). The difficulty, as Reno describes it, is the overlapping perspectives regarding the Bible as an historical document, as a work of literature, and as an explanation of divine Truth.…