Political Thought

Imagine Reevaluation of Political Philosophies…

By Justin Katz | February 29, 2012 |

… It may be more difficult than it seems. If dislike of dictators Is contingent on progressive dreams Over on the Current, I express restrained hope that some noise on the Left about Central Falls’ receiver will spur reconsideration of liberals’ long-running centralization project. I note, too, that Anchor Rising’s unease with the entire municipal…

False Denials of Comparison Between Roads and Families

By Justin Katz | January 31, 2012 |

In further proof of his lax moral standards,* it took Mangeek too long to read my post responding to one of his recent comments for his own response to attract much attention, so I’ll reprint it here: … what I’m trying to say, Justin, is that I think conservatives (for the most part) are finding…

Dismissing the Fundamental Political Question

By Justin Katz | January 25, 2012 |

Marc’s post, yesterday, about the correspondence of a growing gap in wealth and a growing gap in once-expected behaviors between economic classes has led down some interesting roads and, I think, exposed some problematic thinking. One comment worth its own consideration comes from Mangeek: “…shouldn’t hesitate to voice their disapproval of those who defy these…

Trillo’s Flawed Government Theory

By Justin Katz | January 10, 2012 |

I don’t relish the observation, but it seems to me that Rep. Joe Trillo (R, Warwick) is displaying an unhealthy political philosophy in his quest for a Quonset casino: “It would have to be bigger than Foxwoods, bigger than Mohegan Sun, otherwise it’s not going to work,” he said. “To just go with a regional…

The Mood on the Right

By Justin Katz | January 10, 2012 |

Roger Kimball expresses a pessimism with which I confess more than a little sympathy: Tootling around Washington, I was struck by — well, not by its prosperity, exactly, but by what is clearly a lavish outlay of funds — your funds, in fact. Everywhere I turned there were huge building cranes. In one spot, I…

Big Finance Likes Totalitarianism, but Democracy Requires Hard Lessons

By Justin Katz | January 3, 2012 |

I’ll admit that I don’t have much new to say about the continuing activities of the state-appointed budget commission now ruling East Providence: The state-appointed budget commission overseeing the city’s finances convened for the first time Wednesday, chose Michael O’Keefe, a former state budget director, as its president, and established its first priority: improving the…

Open Thread: Traditional Politicking vs. Occupy Wall Street

By Carroll Andrew Morse | December 21, 2011 |

Open thread question, especially to those who have been impressed by at least the energy of the Occupy Wall Street movement: As several hundred people assemble in Pawtuxet this evening, on the shortest day of the year and just a few days before Christmas to make an important decision regarding their future political direction, how…

The Understand Occupy Wall Street, All You Need To Understand is All of Political Philosophy, Part 1

By Carroll Andrew Morse | November 20, 2011 |

Looking towards Marxism to explain Occupy Wall Street, as a number of writers have recently done, doesn’t go far enough to explain the sort-of-movement’s set of agenda items, or its choice of means for achieving its agenda. To fully understand the Occupy Wall Street Protests, its Providence counterpart, and how they differ from the Tea…

Open Thread: Is there a Big Idea in Modern Political Philsophy that’s Not Somewhere in the Work of John Locke, Edmund Burke, or Jean-Jacques Rousseau?

By Carroll Andrew Morse | November 20, 2011 |

I can’t think of a body for this post that makes clearer what’s in the title.

The Cultural Cycle We’re In

By Justin Katz | November 17, 2011 |

Commenting on the image cut by “union protesters” (that is, protesting union members), Alice Losasso of West Warwick quotes Scottish historian Alexander Tytler as follows: “The average age of the world’s greatest civilizations from the beginning of history, has been about 200 years. During those 200 years, these nations always progressed through the following sequence:…