Civil Liberties

Once Again Re: The Direction of Imposition

By Justin Katz | March 11, 2011 |

This started out as a comment to my previous post on the topic, but it began to feel more like a post in its own right. As usual, our left-leaning readers have got me all wrong. I have absolutely no problem with any religion having an exclusive prayer posted in public schools, even with required…

Re: The Direction of Imposition

By Justin Katz | March 11, 2011 |

I’ve been at a loss as to how to respond to the comments to my post this morning about the Cranston school prayer banner, because those who advocate for the removal of the banner are so extreme in their beliefs (even those who are typically reasonable and moderate in their approach) that they appear to…

The Direction of Imposition with Cranston Prayer

By Justin Katz | March 11, 2011 |

The debate over a banner with a prayer in a Cranston public school — which the ACLU attempted to bully the district into moving with the threat of a lawsuit and which the school committee has voted to defend — makes very stark the contrast of the sides. On one side is the fact that…

Opening the Gateway

By Justin Katz | February 4, 2011 |

Drug legalization isn’t an issue about which I’m passionate; when it comes to marijuana, I’m pretty much ambivalent. The fact that Froma Harrop supports legalization does make me wonder whether the opposite view might be wiser. In that regard, Providence College history professor Richard Grace makes some reasonable points: One wonders whether the real goal…

When One Group’s Ascendency Must Prevent Another’s

By Justin Katz | February 3, 2011 |

It’s fascinating to hear people who wish to radically alter the law and culture by any means necessary and silence their opposition attempt to explain why the other side is the home of oppression and closed mindedness. One specimen of the genre, oddly not apparently online, comes courtesy David Adams Murphy. After introducing his subject…

The Scope of Religious Freedom

By Justin Katz | February 2, 2011 |

A recent article (apparently not online) in The Rhode Island Catholic summarized same-sex marriage legislation introduced to the General Assembly as follows: Both Chafee and House Speaker Gordon Fox support allowing same-sex couples to marry. Last Thursday, Rep. Arthur Handy and Sen. Rhoda Perry filed bills that would recognize “civil marriage” between same gender individuals,…

The Bully and the Protector

By Justin Katz | January 25, 2011 |

There’s no question that technology creates all sorts of challenges and that cyberbullying is among them. Just think of the malice that would have been required to do something similar in the past: Nailing nasty fliers around town took a lot more effort than posting a Facebook page, indicating a greater pathology. Yet, the effect…

A Possibility of New Precedent Affecting the Cranston West Banner

By Carroll Andrew Morse | December 22, 2010 |

Would there be room in the public sphere — specifically, within the the Cranston West High School cafeteria auditorium — for a banner beginning with the words “Heavenly Father”, if the most recent Establishment Clause precedent issued by the United States Supreme Court were to say that a relevant lower court decision was flawed, because…The…

Global X-Ray Vision… Without a Warrant

By Justin Katz | October 21, 2010 |

Have you caught wind of this story? Yasir Afifi, a 20-year-old computer salesman and community college student, took his car in for an oil change earlier this month and his mechanic spotted an odd wire hanging from the undercarriage. The wire was attached to a strange magnetic device that puzzled Afifi and the mechanic. They…

Extremists Among Us

By Justin Katz | August 20, 2010 |

You know, it’s stories like this that make the ACLU — periodically correct positions notwithstanding — seem like an extremist group: The ACLU claims [Woonsocket public schools’ dress code] policy, adopted April 14, violates the right to free speech by prohibiting students from expressing their views on any topic. “Uniforms may be useful in prison…